What were librarians doing while Otlet was inventing documentation? The modernization and professionalization of librarianship during the Belle Époque


In the historiography of librarianship and information work, the development of librarianship during the Belle Époque (1871-1914) has been somewhat overshadowed by the heroic and ultimately unsuccessful projects of Otlet, the Royal Society, and others to bring about bibliographic control of the world’s scholarly literature. In this article, an attempt is made to determine the issues which preoccupied an emerging Anglo-American library profession during this period. It is based on evidence provided by a selection of British and American documents and events from the 1850s onwards which were influential at that time, including Britain’s Public Libraries Act of 1850; the first world’s fairs in the early 1850s; Edward Edward’s Free town libraries of 1869; the formative events surrounding the 1876 United States Centennial Exposition; Melvil Dewey’s School of Library Economy (established 1887); and James Duff Brown’s Manual of library economy of 1903. Librarians’ concerns at the turn of the twentieth century are discussed in relation to societal trends affecting the modernization and professionalization of librarianship.


Librarianship; Anglo-American; Belle Époque; Professionalization; Modernization; USA; UK.

Full Text:





Battles, Matthew. 2015. Library: An Unquiet History. New York: W.W. Norton & Company.

Black, Alistair. 2016. “The Librarian as Observer, Ambassador, and Tourist: Visits by Three Mid-Twentieth-Century British Librarians to the United States.” Library & Information History 32 (1–2): 146–59. Doi: 10.1080/17583489.2015.1128636.

Black, Alistair, and Peter Hoare. 2006. “Libraries in the Modern World.” In The Cambridge History of Libraries in Britain and Ireland, edited by Peter Hoare, Elizabeth Leedham-Greene, Teresa Webber, Giles Mandelbrote, K. A. Manley, and Alistair Black, 3:7–18. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Doi: 10.1017/CHOL9780521780971.003.

Black, Alistair, and Dan Schiller. 2014. “Systems of Information: The Long View”. Library Trends 62 (3): 628–62. Doi: 10.1353/lib.2014.0009.

Brown, James Duff. 1898. Manual of Library Classification and Shelf Arrangement; London: Library Supply Company.

———. 1903. Manual of Library Economy. London: Scott, Greenwood & co.

———. 1906. Subject Classification; with Tables, Indexes, Etc. for the Sub-Division of Subjects. London: Library Supply Company.

Carpenter, Michael. 1994. “Catalogs and Cataloging.” In Encyclopedia of Library History, edited by Wayne A. Wiegand and Donald G. Davis, 107–17. Garland Reference Library of Social Science 503. New York: Routledge.

Carroll, Mary, Paulette Kerr, Abdullahi I. Musa, and Waseem Afzal. 2013. “Commonwealth of Uncertainty: How British and American Professional Models of Library Practice Have Shaped LIS Education in Selected Former British Colonies and Dominions.” IFLA Journal 39 (2):121–33. Doi: 10.1177/0340035213486405.

Carroll, Mary, and Sue Reynolds. 2014. “The Great Classification Battle of 1910: A Tale of ‘Blunders and Bizzareries’ at the Melbourne Public Library.” In Information beyond Borders: International and Cultural Exchange in the Belle Époque, edited by W. Boyd Rayward, 244–57. Aldershot, England: Ashgate.

Coblans, Herbert. 1974. Librarianship and Documentation: An International Perspective. London: André Deutsch/Grafton Books.

Cole, John Y. 1993. “Jefferson’s Legacy: A Brief History of the Library of Congress.” Library of Congress.

Columbia College Library. 1885. School of Library Economy: Circular of Information 1885. New York: Columbia University.

———. 1887. School of Library Economy: Circular of Information 1887-8. New York: Columbia University.

Edwards, Edward. (1869) 2010. Free Town Libraries, Their Formation, Management, and History in Britain, France, Germany, and America; Together with Brief Notices of Book-Collectors, and of the Respective Places of Deposit of Their Surviving Collections. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Doi: 10.1017/CBO9780511694592.

Emard, Jean Paul. 1976. “An Information Science Chronology in Perspective.” Bulletin of the American Society for Information Science 2 (8):51–57.

Ford, Anne. 2018. “Bringing the Harassment out of the History Books: Addressing the Troubling Aspects of Melvil Dewey’s Legacy.” American Libraries 49 (6):48–52.

Gambee, Bud L. 1968. “Best Foot Forward: Representation of American Librarianship at World’s Fairs, 1853-1904.” In Library History Seminar No. 3 Proceedings, 1968, edited by Martha Jane K. Zachert, 137–74. Tallahassee FL: Journal of library history.

Harris, Michael H. 1975. The Role of the Public Library in American Life a Speculative Essay. University of Illinois Graduate School of Library and Information Science. Occasional Papers 117. Urbana IL: University of Illinois Graduate School of Library and Information Science.

———. 1999. History of Libraries of the Western World. Lanham MD: Scarecrow Press.

Harris, Neil. 1981. “Cultural Institutions and American Modernization.” The Journal of Library History (1974-1987) 16 (1):28–47.

Huffman, Wallace E., and Robert E. Evenson. 2006. Science for Agriculture: A Long-Term Perspective. 2nd ed. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.

Lee, Michael Min-song. 1979. “Melvil Dewey (1851-1931): His Educational Contributions and Reforms.” PhD Dissertation, Chicago: Loyola University of Chicago.

Lor, Peter Johan. 2019. International and Comparative Librarianship: Concepts and Methods for Global Studies. Global Studies in Libraries and Information 4. Berlin; Boston: De Gruyter/Saur.

Ludington, Flora B. 1954. “The American Contribution to Foreign Library Establishment and Rehabilitation.” In International Aspects of Librarianship, edited by Leon Carnovsky, 112–24. University of Chicago Studies in Library Science. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Miksa, Francis L. 1983. “Melvil Dewey and the Corporate Ideal.” In Melvil Dewey: The Man and the Classification, edited by Grace T. Stevenson and J. Kramer-Greene, 49–100. Albany NY: Forest Press.

———. 1986. “Melvil Dewey: The Professional Educator and His Heirs.” Library Trends 34 (3):359–81.

———. 1988. “The Columbia School of Library Economy, 1887-1888.” Libraries & Culture 23 (3):249–80.

Miller, Edward. 1979. “Antonio Panizzi and the British Museum.” Electronic British Library Journal, Article 1, 1−17.

Minter, Catherine J. 2018. “Munich to Manhattan: German Bibliothekswissenschaft and the Beginnings of North American Library Science Education.” Library & Information History 34 (4):197–216. Doi: 10.1080/17583489.2018.1554837.

Mogren, Eric W. 1999. “Henri-Marie La Fontaine.” In Dictionary of World Biography, edited by Frank N. Magill, 8:2051–53. London-New York: Routledge.

Murra, Kathrine O. 1951. “History of Some Attempts to Organize Bibliography Internationally.” In Bibliographic Organization. Papers Presented before the Fifteenth Annual Conference of the Graduate Library School, July 24-29, 1950, edited by Jesse Hauk Shera and Margaret E. Egan, 24–53. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Olle, James G. 1977. “The Library Association and the American Library Association: Their First Fifty Years.” Journal of Librarianship 9 (4):247–60.

Passet, Joanne E. 1994. “Itinerating Libraries.” In Encyclopedia of Library History, edited by Wayne A. Wiegand and Donald G. Davis, 315–17. Garland Reference Library of Social Science 503. New York-London: Garland Publishing.

Public Libraries in the United States of America: Their History, Condition and Management. Special Report. 1876. Washington DC: Government Printing Office, for Department of the Interior, Bureau of Education.

Ranfa, Elena. 2013. “Paul Otlet: una vita per la documentazione.” AIB Studi 53 (1):45–62.

Rayward, W. Boyd. 1975. The Universe of Information: The Work of Paul Otlet for Documentation and International Organisation. Moscow: Viniti.

———. 1976. “Librarianship in the New World and the Old: Some Points of Contact.” Library Trends 25 (July):209–26.

———. 1981. “The Evolution of an International Library and Bibliographic Community.” Journal of Library History 16 (2):449-462.

———. 1991. “The Case of Paul Otlet, Pioneer of Information Science, Internationalist, Visionary: Reflections on Biography.” Journal of Librarianship and Information Science 23 (3):135–45. Doi: 10.1177/096100069102300303.

———. 1993. “International Library and Bibliographic Organisations.” In World Encyclopedia of Library and Information Services, edited by Robert Wedgeworth, 3rd ed., 382–87. Chicago: American Library Association.

———. 1997. “The Origins of Information Science and the International Institute of Bibliography/International Federation for Information and Documentation.” Journal of the American Society for Information Science 48 (4):289–300.

———. 2003. “Knowledge Organisation and a New World Polity: The Rise and Fall and Rise of the Ideas of Paul Otlet.” Transnational Associations, no. 1-2:4–15.

———. 2014. “Introduction: International Exhibitions, Paul Otlet, Henri La Fontaine and the Paradox of the Belle Époque.” In Information beyond Borders: International and Cultural Exchange in the Belle Époque, edited by W. Boyd Rayward, 1–22. Aldershot, England: Ashgate.

“Report of the Trustees of the Public Library of the City of Boston.” 1852. City Document No. 37. Boston MA: City of Boston.

Rubin, Richard E. 2004. Foundations of Library and Information Science. 2nd ed. Chicago: Neal-Schuman Publishers.

Rudomino, Margarita I. 1977. “The Prehistory of IFLA (Recalling the History of International Library Congresses).” In IFLA’s First Fifty Years; Achievements and Challenges in International Librarianship, edited by Willem R. H. Koops and Joachim Wieder, 101–7. IFLA Publications 10. Munich: Verlag Dokumentation. Doi: 10.1515/9783111356655.66.

School of Library Economy of Columbia College, 1887-1889; Documents for a History. 1937. New York: School of Library Service, Columbia University.

Trautman, Ray. 1954. A History of the School of Library Service Columbia University. Columbia University Press.

Tucker, John Mark, and Edward A. Goedeken. 2010. “History of Libraries.” In Encyclopedia of Library and Information Sciences, edited by Marcia J. Bates and Mary Niles Maack, 3rd ed., 2080–95. New York: Taylor & Francis. Doi: 10.1081/E-ELIS3-120043544.

Weller, Toni. 2011. “Introduction.” In Information History in the Modern World: Histories of the Information Age, edited by Toni Weller, 1–12. Themes in Focus. Basingstoke, England; New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

Whitehill, Walter Muir. 1956. Boston Public Library: A Centennial History. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.

Article Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Metrics powered by PLOS ALM


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2019 Peter Johan Lor

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. is a journal of UNIFI-SAGAS published by EUM - edizioni università di macerata